Contribute to the Worship and Witness Capital Campaign by clicking the star icon

What's the difference between Christianity and a cult?

Welcome to Theology Thursday! Theology is the study of God, his relation to the world, and our relation to him; it is "faith seeking understanding." I hope these newsletters help enhance your faith and deepen your love for God and his people, the church.

Today's question:
What's the difference between Christianity and a cult?

Pastor Brady's thoughts:
“Oh, that church has the reputation of being cult-y.”

Have you ever heard anyone say that about a church before? I had someone say that to me about MCC recently, and though they were remembering their perception of MCC several decades ago, it still bothered me.

Usually, these types of comments come from two types of people. The first is the people who are totally unchurched and have very little familiarity with church things; all of it seems foreign and weird to them (because it is!). People singing, chanting, reading out loud in unison, giving money, following a leader who has a centralized/outsized presence among the group? Weird. Cult-y, to those who don’t know the difference.

The second group is the people who are nominally part of a church that leans very heavily toward the seeker-attractional model with no real church membership or discipline practices where most people kind of come and go, shuffling in and out without ever really belonging to the congregation in a meaningful way. Attenders of these types of churches can look at churches that take the formal commitment of membership seriously and make snide statements about cultishness.

To be fair, some churches do over-do it. They add rules and expectations to their policies and teaching that aren’t in scripture and it leads to an insular environment, a negative attitude about other churches, and, often, the elevation of a particular leader to an unhealthy level of adoration and spiritual deferment.

But most churches do not deserve the label of “cult.” The vast majority don’t even come close. Most are doing their best to honor God and, even when they fail or fall short, still can’t really be considered cultish.

So, what are the differences between churches and cults? There are probably lots more, but three specific distinctions come to mind:

One, cults are about allegiance to a human leader (Christians worship Jesus, who is much more than human).  

Christians follow human leaders, too, of course. Pastors, elders, bishops, teachers, and other spiritual leaders have real authority within the church. The difference is that a healthy Christian church understands that its leaders are under authority themselves.

A pastor isn't the center of Christianity; Jesus is.

That sounds obvious, but it has enormous implications. A Christian leader doesn't get to redefine Christianity simply because people trust him or her. The pastor doesn't become the final interpreter of scripture. The congregation's loyalty isn't ultimately to the pastor's personality, preferences, charisma, or vision. The pastor is a servant of Christ and is accountable to something - and Someone - greater than himself.

This is one of the reasons the New Testament repeatedly warns against putting Christian leaders on pedestals. Paul gets almost comically blunt about this in 1st Corinthians when Christians begin dividing themselves around personalities: “I follow Paul,” “I follow Apollos,” etc. Paul's response is essentially: “What are you doing? I’m not the one who was crucified for you.”

That's the danger when a church becomes centered around a human leader. Eventually, disagreement with the leader begins to feel like disagreement with God. Questioning the leader becomes rebellion. Leaving the leader becomes abandoning the faith. The leader's opinions become indistinguishable from biblical truth.

That's where things can become genuinely cultic, because cults are all about a particular leader’s vision, desires, and control. No gospel-focused church should ever look like that.

A healthy church should actually make it easier for people to distinguish between “This is what Jesus and scripture require” and “This is what our pastor thinks.” The former demands obedience; the latter invites discernment.

Christians aren't ultimately asked to surrender themselves to a charismatic human personality. They're called to become disciples of Christ. That also means that a pastor should be able to say, in effect, “Don't follow me because I'm me. Follow me insofar as I am faithfully pointing you to Christ.”

Cults are centered on the person in the middle of the circle; Christianity is centered on the person on the cross.

Two, cults don’t allow the freedom to exit (you can leave a church whenever you want).

This distinction needs a little nuance, because a church can make leaving emotionally difficult and a cult can theoretically say, “You're free to leave,” while making the consequences of leaving terrifying.

So the real issue isn't merely whether the door is technically unlocked; it's whether a person's freedom and conscience remain intact.

Church membership involves commitment. That's actually one of the things that distinguishes a church from a loose religious gathering. When you join a church, you are saying something meaningful: These are my people. I am committing myself to their spiritual welfare, and I am allowing them to hold me accountable.

The New Testament has a category for that kind of commitment. Hebrews tells Christians to encourage one another. Paul describes the church as a body in which members belong to one another. Jesus gives the church a process for confronting serious sin. Christian community isn't supposed to be completely individualistic.

But commitment isn't the same as captivity.

A healthy church can say, “We don't want you to leave, and we'd love to understand why you're leaving,” without saying, “You are not allowed to leave,” or “We’re going to shame you or threaten you for leaving.”

It can grieve someone's departure without demonizing them, it can disagree with someone's decision without threatening them, and it can practice church discipline without attempting to control every aspect of someone's life.

And perhaps most importantly, a person's relationship with Jesus cannot ultimately be made contingent upon remaining in one particular congregation.

This is another place where the distinction between authority and control becomes important. Churches have legitimate authority over their members in certain areas of Christian life. But that authority is limited. A pastor doesn't own his congregation, elders don't own the members, and the church doesn't own people's consciences.

When a religious organization begins demanding control over friendships, romantic relationships, employment, finances, housing, education, political choices, or contact with outsiders - and treats resistance as spiritual rebellion - it has moved well beyond ordinary Christian discipleship.

A healthy church says, “Come, belong, commit, serve, grow, and let’s walk together.”

A cult says, “You belong to us, and leaving us means losing everything.”

Three, cults are naturally individual-focused (churches are missional-focused).  

This one may need the most explanation because, at first glance, it sounds backwards. After all, cults often seem intensely communal. They eat together, live together, work (or not) together, and spend enormous amounts of time together. Meanwhile, many ordinary Christians seem pretty individualistic.

So what do I mean by “individually focused”?

I think the distinction is not how much time people spend together; it's what the community ultimately exists to accomplish.

A cult tends to become self-referential. The group exists for the preservation, growth, protection, or glorification of the group itself - and often its leader. The outside world becomes a threat. Outsiders don't understand. Critics are enemies. Leaving is betrayal. The group's survival becomes an end in itself. It’s all about finding oneself and attempting to realize one’s physical and emotional desires.

The church, by contrast, is supposed to be missional.

The church does not exist to make church members happier, safer, or more comfortable. It exists to participate in the mission of God.

Jesus doesn't gather his disciples and say, “Congratulations. You've found the right community. Now let's spend the rest of our lives protecting this community from everybody else.”

He sends them. Go. Make disciples. Love your neighbor. Care for the poor. Welcome the stranger. Turn the other cheek. Proclaim the gospel. Wash feet. Serve the world.

Even, pay your taxes!

Not very cult-y.

In other words, the church gathers in order to be sent.

That distinction also changes how a good church thinks about itself. A healthy congregation shouldn't be obsessed with its own survival, reputation, preferences, traditions, or institutional success. It should certainly care about those things to some degree - churches have budgets, buildings, ministries, and responsibilities - but those things are means rather than the mission itself.

The question isn't, “How do we get more people into our church?” It's “How does God want to use this church for the sake of people who aren't here yet?”

That’s a very different - and better - thing.

And there's another important implication: a healthy church doesn't need to isolate its members in order to preserve their faith. Christians are supposed to be sent into the world, not hidden from it. The church should produce people who can leave the building and love their neighbors, serve their communities, work faithfully in their professions, engage people who don't share their beliefs, and embody the gospel outside the congregation.

A cult tends to say, “Stay close to us because we're the only safe place.”

The church says, “We're here to equip you to go.”

Conclusion

The difference between Christianity and a cult isn't simply how much commitment is required; it's what kind of commitment is being demanded, who possesses ultimate authority, and what the community is ultimately for.

A Christian church can ask a great deal of its members. It can ask for commitment, sacrifice, generosity, accountability, service, repentance, and obedience.

But it cannot legitimately say: “Your ultimate loyalty belongs to us.” Because it doesn't. Our ultimate allegiance belongs to Christ.

If you’re ever in the situation of needing to discern the health of some group - a “church” or otherwise - for yourself or others, you can ask these three questions of its participants:

Who do you ultimately follow?

Are you free to be who God created you to be (and are you free to do it somewhere else besides right here in this specific group)?

What is your mission?


Christianity has structures of authority, commitment, and community - but those structures are ordained by the Bible, deliberately limited, and ordered toward Christ and his mission.

When those structures become centered on a human being, coercive rather than voluntary, and self-preserving rather than missional, you've crossed into something fundamentally different.

TO KNOW GOD AND TO MAKE HIM KNOWN!
- Pastor Brady

Have a question for Theology Thursday? Send an email to office@minierchristian.org and we'll respond, or we'll include in a future Theology Thursday Buffet.


Recent

Categories

Archive

 2026
 2025

Tags